Though my name is Scott, I like so many Americans am also Irish, thanks to my Grandma McGee. In fact though she lived in Oregon for more than sixty years, she never became a US citizen.
Yet I have done nothing about this and remain only a US citizen…nor do I intend to. First, it’s a lot of work registering that Irish citizenship…getting all the documents together and such. Yet there are other reasons…we’ll see in a moment.
In a recent discussion with a friend, who was also a dual national, I learned that he gave up his American citizenship.
His reasons were good but for many this does not make sense. The second reason I remain in the US…this is one of the countries I know my way around best. I have friends and family and a terrific support system developed here.
The number one rule for good investing and business is to do what you love. Rule #2 is to do or invest in what you know.
I love the US, this magnificent country and the wonderful people so the US is a good place for me to be.
Too few people who leave the US think of this personal aspect. They become so caught up in high taxation or the bad parts of this nation’s evolution and want to leave. I do not blame them but recommend that they are sure they know where they are going before they irrevocably leave the US.
While recently visiting friends in Seattle, I was talking with their cleaning lady and her daughter from the Czech Republic. They told me how they had moved to America to be in the land of the free and to live the American dream. Now they are going back for better opportunity in Eastern Europe. Plus they feel they will have more freedom there.
For the Czech couple, this may make sense. They know the Czech Republic and have more friends, family and support back in their original home.
This is a pretty bad commentary on America where opportunity used to be so good that to was worth giving up the old for the new.
Now maybe it’s not. So many freedoms have been lost in America. So many new regulations have been been born. Life is now so complicated. America is burdened with an overworked tort system, a failing health and insurance system and monumental federal debt that has and continues to destroy the dollar.
Many Americans feel stifled. Many fear things will get even worse.
There can be tax benefits to moving abroad (though new tax laws tax those who leave and any gifts they give to Americans before they leave). It is certainly easier to open a bank account abroad if you are not a US citizen, plus if one has immigrated, a citizenship elsewhere can make life in one’s new country easier and better as well.
Plus I know from living abroad for decades how one feels out from under the eye “Big Brother”, once you live in another country.
Despite these facts, (this may seem strange for me, as one of the first proponents of being a one man multi national), I have no plans to abandon my US citizenship….nor my residence in the US.
This is a well informed choice. I have lived for many years in Asia, Europe and Latin America as well as the US….so my choice is based on experience.
This global lifestyle has confirmed one important fact….every country has its great good points and its flaws.
If I know and like the US, have children and grandchildren here…why move?
Why spend the time and resources to make a switch?
I see nothing wrong with changing citizenships, especially for those who earn and live abroad, but except in certain cases, I wonder if the benefits are worth the effort?
Instead I devote my efforts to maintaining flexibility and utilizing options.
To me flexibility in earning and asset allocation are more important than citizenship because change is taking place everywhere. I would rather be a US citizen and have one or two other places to go if everything goes south here, than abandon one of the places I know best, for somewhere new that could have negative changes as well.
America has problems but regrettably as the world’s biggest economy leads the way for other nations to follow.
Take federal deficit spending as an example. For many years it was easy to invest out of the US dollar. The American government was a spendthrift going deeper and deeper into a more of debt. Other industrial, nations, especially Germany and Japan were much more fiscally prudent. The the Japanese and German’s learned from the US how to borrow massively every time the economy slowed.
There is a great erosion of freedom in other countries also not just the US.
Let’s look at some specifics.
A July 2 USA Today article entitled “IRS gets OK to request UBS information” says:
“A federal judge in Miami authorized the Internal Revenue Service to request information from UBS about U.S. taxpayers who may be using Swiss bank accounts to evade federal income taxes,” the Justice Department said Tuesday.
“The so-called John Doe summons is used to obtain information about possible tax fraud by people whose identities are unknown. The judge granted the government’s request for a court order a day after it made what a Justice Department spokesman called an unprecedented request for the records. The order ‘directs UBS to produce records identifying U.S. taxpayers with accounts at UBS in Switzerland who elected to have their accounts remain hidden from the IRS,’ the Justice Department said in a statement.”
To me this is a horrible breach of law. How can UBS know if a taxpayer has their account hidden from the IRS?
Yet the US is not alone. Take the UK as an example. I love England was resident there for a decade in this nation and was resident there for many years…but the wonderful freedoms of the Common Law have been eroding just ike in the US.
A recent article at Telegraph.com entitled “Safety deposit box raids yield £1bn of drugs, cash and guns” by Richard Edwards, says:
“Police have seized a potential £1 billion ‘treasure trove’ of cash, drugs and guns in an unprecedented raid on concrete vaults holding 7,000 safety deposit boxes.
Police officers close Park Street in Mayfair before raiding Park Lane Safe Deposit in connection with suspected money laundering operations.”
“Members of the public who have innocently and legally stored their valuables were ‘inevitably’ going to get swept up in the disruption, it was predicted. Police said they could use a freephone number – 0800 030 4613 – to claim back their goods.”
In both cases, innocent parties who have done nothing illegal nor even irregular are going to be inconvenienced at the least.
Let’s look at Canada in another example. Many Canadians are in a fuss over the proposed C-51 laws. WWW.stop c51 warns Canadians that Bill C-51 will allow government agents to:
* Enter private property without a warrant Section 23 (4)
* Confiscate your property at their discretion, at your cost Section 23.3 a
* Dispose of your property at their discretion, at your cost Section 23.3 c
* Seize your bank accounts without a warrant Section 23 (2)
* Levy fines of up to $5,000,000.00 / 2 years in jail per offense. Section 31.1
* Allow laws to be created in Canada, behind closed doors, with the assistance of foreign governments, industrial and trade organizations Section 30.7
* Allow ‘Crack house style’ of enforcement on natural health providers
Plus the site warns more losses of freedom.
There is a government site that says this law will not create these problems but one wonders. When income tax was first introduced in the US, it was promised it would never rise beyond 2%!
America has enormous tort problems. Every US business worries about lawsuits,
but before you move to France to escape this problem read this article:
“A French court on Monday ordered the online auction giant eBay to pay 38.6 million euros, or $61 million, in damages to the French luxury goods company LVMH, in the latest round in a long-running legal battle over the sale of counterfeit goods on the Internet.
“LVMH, a maker of high-end leather goods, perfumes and other fashion and luxury products, successfully challenged eBay for a second time in the French court, arguing that 90 percent of the Louis Vuitton bags and Dior perfumes sold on eBay are fakes.
“The court ruled that eBay, which earns a commission on the sales, was not doing enough to stamp out counterfeit sales.”
Change is everywhere. We should always look for a balance in our living, earning and investing, that fits our lifestyle and circumstances. We should seek flexibility and options…but remember that problems are everywhere.
Thank God for problems. Problems are a sign of evolution and problems create opportunity. Who wants to live in a land without opportunity?
The problems we see from eroding freedoms are not dilemmas unique to the USA.
They are problems of increased populations all trying to do and have more. Life seems more complicated today because it is more complicated in some ways.
The more moving parts a machine has…the more likely it will break. Our social systems have more and more people moving faster and governments working to do just that-govern. One definition of govern is: “manipulate b: to control the speed of (as a machine) especially by automatic means.”
Wherever you live…work…earn look for the problems and figure out the opportunity. If part of that opportunity comes in the form of a new residence or citizenship…that’s great. Go for it…yet realize that this is not the best solution for everyone.
Until next message, may all your freedom come from within and all your problems be good.
Learn ways to increase your earnings options though international business.
Join us on the farm.
Enjoy our deep woods hot tub.
Join us and stay at our farm for Susan Rotman’s business intuition course.
Enjoy the mountain cool and summer views as you learn.
Study our online correspondence courses:
Here is what a reader recently wrote about this course:
“We are now generating business from our Ecuador site www.retire-in-ecuador.com. People are responding to go and live in Ecuador. Our imports from Ecuador are also going well. We have only been trading for 6 weeks, and some customers (gift shops) have re-ordered four times. We only need 100 like them and we will have a sustainable business. We are currently establishing about 10 new customers per week, and are in the process of appointing agents for the other states. We will soon have an “Andes Artisans” site operating www.andes-artisans.com. So keep an eye out.”